On Friday’s episode of First Take, Stephen A. Smith unleashed a fiery rant aimed at the New York Giants, accusing the organization of contacting ESPN executives to complain about host Elle Duncan’s criticism of quarterback Daniel Jones. However, according to The New York Post, Smith’s claim was entirely unfounded.
During his heated monologue, Smith lambasted the Giants organization, referencing their lackluster performance since 2011 and their handling of criticism toward Jones.
Stephen A. Smith hot take on Aaron Rodgers future
“The New York Giants, respectfully, shut the hell up,” Smith declared. “Since 2011, you’ve made the playoffs twice and won one game. And you’ve got the nerve to call executives about someone doing their job? Why don’t you do your damn job?”
But it turns out the alleged call to ESPN never happened. While Giants senior VP of communications Pat Hanlon criticized Duncan’s comments on X (formerly Twitter), no one from the team contacted ESPN offices, let alone complained to executives. ESPN declined to comment on the discrepancy, leaving Smith’s dramatic accusations in question.
Elle Duncan’s controversial comments
The controversy began earlier in the week when Duncan mocked Daniel Jones during her Taking the Elle segment. Referring to Jones‘ prepared post-game comments after being benched, Duncan quipped:
I’m sorry you paid me $108 million for one playoff win. I look forward to reviving my career as Brock Purdy’s backup. The end.
Duncan faced backlash on social media for her remarks, which many considered harsh given Jones‘ emotional gratitude toward his team. Still, Duncan doubled down on her stance, addressing the backlash with a tongue-in-cheek comment about “snowflakes” on X.
Giants’ turbulent season
The Giants‘ struggles extend beyond off-field drama. With a dismal 3-8 record, the team has turned to third-string quarterback Tommy DeVito to start against the Buccaneers. Daniel Jones, who signed a $108 million contract extension, has dropped to fourth on the depth chart following the signing of Tim Boyle.
As the Giants navigate a disappointing season, Smith’s rant highlights the frustration surrounding the team-but his inaccurate claim casts doubt on his credibility in this instance.
