The NFL Most Valuable Player (MVP) award is the most prestigious individual accolade in professional football. It’s a symbol of dominance, consistency, and sheer brilliance on the gridiron. Over the years, legendary quarterbacks and a few standout running backs have etched their names in history by winning multiple MVP awards.

So, who holds the record for the most MVP trophies? Let’s break it down.

Related:

Who Has Won the Most NFL MVP Awards?

1. Peyton Manning – 5 MVPs (2003, 2004, 2008, 2009, 2013)

The Sheriff stands alone atop the MVP mountain. Peyton Manning is the only player in NFL history to win the award five times. His football IQ, pinpoint accuracy, and ability to read defenses made him one of the most dominant quarterbacks ever.

• First MVP (2003 & 2004): Manning shared his first award with Steve McNair in 2003 and won outright in 2004 after a 49-touchdown season.
• Back-to-Back (2008 & 2009): He again won in consecutive years, proving his consistent greatness.
• Final MVP (2013): Manning’s record-breaking 5,477-yard, 55-touchdown season with the Denver Broncos earned him his last MVP.

No one has surpassed Peyton’s five MVPs-yet.

2. Aaron Rodgers – 4 MVPs (2011, 2014, 2020, 2021)

Aaron Rodgers might be one of the most talented quarterbacks to ever play the game. His arm talent, mobility, and ability to limit turnovers have kept him in MVP conversations for over a decade.

• 2011: 45 TDs, 4,643 yards, and a Super Bowl follow-up.
• 2014: Efficient, explosive, and led the Packers to a 12-4 record.
• 2020 & 2021: A resurgence at 37 years old, winning back-to-back MVPs while keeping the Packers as NFC contenders.

At 40, Rodgers is still active-could he tie Manning’s record?

3. Tom Brady – 3 MVPs (2007, 2010, 2017)

Brady’s seven Super Bowls might overshadow his MVP count, but he still took home the honor three times.

• 2007: The historic 16-0 Patriots season with 50 TDs.
• 2010: Another efficient year with 36 TDs and just four interceptions.
• 2017: At 40 years old, Brady proved age is just a number with 4,577 yards and 32 TDs.

Considering his longevity and success, many argue he should have won more.

Other Notable Multi-Time MVP Winners

• Patrick Mahomes – 2 MVPs (2018, 2023)
• Steve Young – 2 MVPs (1992, 1994)
• Kurt Warner – 2 MVPs (1999, 2001)
• Joe Montana – 2 MVPs (1989, 1990)
• Steve McNair – 1.5 MVPs (2003, shared with Manning)
• Lamar Jackson – 2 MVPs (2019, 2023)

Could Patrick Mahomes Break the Record?

With two MVPs and already two Super Bowl MVPs under his belt, Patrick Mahomes is the best candidate to challenge Manning’s record. If he continues to dominate the league, a few more MVPs seem likely.

Other potential future MVP winners include:

• Josh Allen (Bills) – If he cleans up his turnovers, he has the talent.
• Joe Burrow (Bengals) – If he stays healthy, he could rack up awards.
• Lamar Jackson (Ravens) – He already has two and is in his prime.
• Jalen Hurts (Eagles) – A dynamic dual-threat quarterback.

The NFL MVP race is always competitive, with new stars emerging every year. Peyton Manning’s five MVPs remain the gold standard, but Rodgers, Mahomes, and others could challenge that mark.

With every season, the MVP conversation ignites debates among fans, analysts, and players alike. One thing is for sure: the pursuit of greatness never stops.