Tyler Allgeier’s NFL path has never been loud, but it has been consistent. Since arriving as a fifth-round pick in 2022, the running back carved out a role through production rather than promises, becoming a steady presence in the Atlanta Falcons offense. As free agency approaches, that reliability is pushing him into the spotlight.
Allgeier burst onto the scene with a 1,035-yard rookie season and a franchise record for rushing yards by a first-year Falcon. It was a strong start that suggested long-term value, especially for a team that wanted to reestablish its run game. But roster dynamics change quickly in the NFL, and Atlanta’s plans shifted a year later.
Trevon Diggs gets released by the Packers even though he wanted to stay in the team
The selection of Bijan Robinson eighth overall in 2023 created a shared backfield. The arrangement worked on Sundays, with both backs rotating and producing, but it also complicated contract decisions. With Robinson entrenched as the centerpiece, Atlanta now faces a familiar calculation at the position.
“The Cowboys saw a resurgence in their ability to run the football this season… Williams turned out a career year (81.7 PFF rushing grade); however, the depth behind him left much to be desired. With Williams scheduled to enter free agency – albeit with the possibility of returning to Dallas – the Cowboys should invest more into this backfield…
Why Dallas keeps coming up
That is where the Dallas Cowboys enter the conversation. Dallas profiles as a strong fit if Allgeier reaches the open market. The Cowboys leaned back into the run in 2025, but their depth chart remains unsettled.
Javonte Williams led Dallas in rushing last season and posted a career-best PFF rushing grade, yet he is also headed for free agency. PFF analyst Mason Cameron noted that while the Cowboys’ ground game improved, the options behind Williams were thin, making another addition a practical move rather than a luxury.
Allgeier checks several boxes Dallas values. Over the past two seasons, he has earned an 84.0 PFF rushing grade, ranking among the league’s top backs in that span. His eight rushing touchdowns in 2025 marked a personal high, and his running style aligns with an inside zone-heavy scheme.
“Although he’s been overshadowed by Bijan Robinson in Atlanta, Allgeier is quietly one of the NFL’s most productive backs. His 84.0 PFF rushing grade ranks top five among qualifying running backs over the last two seasons, while also not fumbling a single time over that span. As a premier zone runner, Allgeier would fit in well with the Cowboys’ inside zone-heavy scheme…
Perhaps most appealing is his ball security. Allgeier has not fumbled once in his NFL career, opening with a record 676 carries without a turnover. That kind of dependability carries weight for any offense trying to stay efficient.
Even inside Atlanta, his reputation remains strong. Veteran quarterback Kirk Cousins has said Allgeier would start on many teams he has played for. If Dallas decides to reshape its backfield this offseason, the fit feels less speculative and more practical.
