“This is a true story. The events of this film took place in Minnesota in 1987. At the request of the survivors, the names have been changed. Out of respect for the dead, the rest has been told exactly as it occurred.”
These are the famous opening words of the 1996 mystery comedy Fargo. A movie about a desperate car salesman who hatches a plan to kidnap his own wife and pocket the ransom money to solve his mysterious financial troubles. Of course, everything goes completely wrong, and a bloody trail of lies, murder, and Midwestern politeness leads to his ultimate undoing.
If that premise alone sounds interesting, here’s the kicker: Fargo is one of the Coen Brothers’ most iconic films — and it almost didn’t get made. At least, not when it did.
Why the Coen Brothers Made Fargo Instead of The Big Lebowski
In the mid-1990s, Joel and Ethan Coen were deep into writing The Big Lebowski when they hit a major creative snag about 40 pages into the script. Rather than force it, they did what they often do: stepped away and made another movie instead.
That movie was Fargo.
Ironically, this detour not only broke their writer’s block, but resulted in a film that would go on to win Frances McDormand an Academy Award and spawn one of the most successful television franchises of the modern era. Had the Coens powered through The Big Lebowski instead, Fargo — and its iconic cast — might never have existed in the form we know today.
What Fargo Is Really About (Beyond the Crime)
At its core, Fargo is built from several Coen Brothers obsessions:
Kidnapping – A recurring theme in their work (Raising Arizona, The Big Lebowski, Burn After Reading, True Grit, The Man Who Wasn’t There).
Ensemble characters with clashing motivations – Everyone wants something different, and no one communicates well.
Unremarkable endings – The Coens famously resist traditional “wins” for their characters.
Violence colliding with banality – Brutal crimes unfolding amid polite small talk and mundane routines.
In Fargo, all of these elements hit their peak. The Minnesota accents, the dialogue, and the contrast between extreme violence and middle-class niceness create a tone that’s instantly recognizable — and endlessly imitated.
How Fargo Was Made on Just $7 Million
Fargo was produced on a modest $7 million budget, even by 1990s standards. To stretch that money, the Coens opted to shoot on location during an actual Minnesota winter rather than build expensive snowy sets.
That decision paid off visually. The frozen landscapes, endless white horizons, and bleak Midwestern roads give the film an atmosphere that still looks stunning today — even under a modern 4K scan.
Ironically, the winter wasn’t always cooperative. Some scenes required fake snow, and in certain cases, snow had to be shipped in from other cities to maintain continuity. Still, the harsh environment became one of the film’s greatest assets.
Frances McDormand and the Creation of Marge Gunderson
Frances McDormand’s Marge Gunderson is the heart of Fargo, and one of the most quietly radical protagonists of the 1990s. The Coens wrote the role specifically for her before the script was even finished.
Marge’s pregnancy was never intended as a joke. McDormand worked carefully with prosthetics and movement to sell the third-trimester physicality, viewing it as a symbol of toughness and optimism rather than comedy. Solving murders while seven months pregnant isn’t easy — and the film never treats it lightly.
Off camera, McDormand and co-star John Carroll Lynch reportedly developed an entire backstory for Marge and Norm’s marriage. In their shared version, both were once cops, with Marge rising through the ranks while Norm stepped back — a dynamic that explains their gentle, supportive relationship.
And yes: Norm getting up at 4 a.m. to make eggs and coffee remains one of the healthiest marriages in movie history.
How William H. Macy Fought to Play Jerry Lundegaard
William H. Macy was not originally cast as Jerry Lundegaard. In fact, the Coens initially wanted him for a much smaller role as a state trooper. Macy disagreed — strongly.
He repeatedly pushed for another audition, eventually flying to New York and bluntly telling the Coens he was afraid they were “going to screw this up” if they cast someone else. That confidence paid off.
Macy’s portrayal of Jerry — sweaty, desperate, and spiritually hollow — became one of the great performances of his career. His Midwestern Lutheran upbringing proved to be all the preparation he needed.
Is Fargo Really a True Story?
Despite the opening title card, Fargo is not a true story — at least not in a literal sense.
According to Joel Coen, the brothers loosely drew inspiration from a real case involving a staged kidnapping that resulted in multiple murders. However, the characters, motivations, and events were almost entirely fictional.
That said, many of the locations were real. The King of Clubs bar existed until the early 2000s, Jerry’s dealership was a functioning car lot, and much of the suburban and rural scenery was filmed in authentic Midwestern towns.
That grounding in reality is part of why the film feels so believable, even when it becomes absurd.
The Wood Chipper Scene and Fargo’s Legacy
Steve Buscemi and Peter Stormare’s hired criminals spiral into chaos, culminating in the infamous wood chipper scene — one of the most indelible images in modern cinema. Whether you’ve seen Fargo or not, you know that moment.
The film went on to gross roughly $25 million theatrically and became a major hit on home video, cementing its legacy. Audiences were drawn to its dark humor, razor-sharp dialogue, and endlessly quotable performances.
Rather than producing a direct sequel, the Coens’ work inspired the anthology television series Fargo, which spans multiple decades and crimes while retaining the tone, themes, and moral weirdness of the original film.
Why Fargo Still Endures
The performances, the locations, the cold, and even the unsatisfying ending all feel authentic. That authenticity — paired with the Coens’ singular voice — is what allowed Fargo to become not just a great movie, but a lasting franchise.
And that’s what happened to Fargo: a film born out of writer’s block, made on a tight budget, grounded in fake truth, and destined to become one of the most influential crime comedies ever made.
Ladies and gentlemen — that is WTF happened to Fargo.
Subscribe to our weekly newsletter
Get the latest movie and TV news, first looks, reviews, and interviews, straight from the JoBlo crew to your inbox.
